Should Kids Have Homework – Know the Pros and Cons

Getting kids to do their homework is one of the most dreaded tasks for a parent. As many tantrums as your kid might throw, you know there is a reason why kids should have homework to be completed. However, recent studies have shown that there might be another side to this arrangement that only some people are aware of. Doing homework is a good thing; it may not always be so. Critics contend that it can lead to unnecessary stress, reduce time for extracurricular activities and family interaction.

Keep reading to explore the pros and cons of homework for children and understand how it affects students, parents, and teachers alike.

Do Kids Need Homework?

The necessity of homework for kids is a debated topic. Supporters argue that homework reinforces learning, builds discipline, and fosters independent study skills. Conversely, critics believe it can cause unnecessary stress, reduce time for other activities, and may not significantly enhance academic performance. Ultimately, whether kids need homework depends on balancing its educational benefits and potential drawbacks to their well-being.

Let’s look at the pros and cons to understand better whether kids truly need homework.

Pros of Having Homework

Homework has long been a staple in the educational process, providing students opportunities to extend their learning beyond the classroom. Here are several key advantages of homework for students:

1. Reinforces Learning

Homework allows students to review and practice what they have learned in class, helping to reinforce and solidify their understanding of key concepts. By understanding and examining what has been practised in the class, your child will be well-versed in it and able to grasp the next material quickly (5).

2. Develops Good Study Habits

Regular homework assignments encourage students to develop and maintain good study habits and time management skills, essential for academic success. During examinations, your child needs to have the habit of diligently going through the textbooks, which homework tends to build up over time.

3. Encourages Independent Learning

It is one of the key benefits of doing homework. By working on assignments outside the classroom, students learn to take responsibility for their learning, fostering independence and self-discipline. Since there is no teacher to correct the mistakes, a child is free to make mistakes here and learn from them later on to avoid them in examinations (4).

4. Involves Parents in Education

Homework allows parents to engage with their child’s education, giving them insight into what is being taught and how their child is progressing. It also helps establish communication with your kid and helps him out with tough problems.

5. Prepares for Future Academic Challenges

Consistent homework assignments help prepare students for the demands of higher education, where independent study and self-motivation are critical.

6. Enhances Critical Thinking and Problem-Solving Skills

Challenging homework tasks can promote critical thinking and problem-solving skills, encouraging students to think deeply and creatively about the material they are studying. Certain assignments require kids to research, refer to the Internet for information, etc. These skills are needed later in life to solve real-life problems.

Cons of Homework

While there are several merits of homework, and it is often seen as a valuable educational tool, it also has drawbacks. Critics argue that excessive homework can negatively impact students’ well-being and development. Below are a few reasons why should kids not have homework:

1. Causes Unnecessary Stress

One of the major reasons that homework is frowned upon is how it is packaged into the school curriculum. Rather than being presented as an opportunity to learn better and deeper, homework feels like an unnecessary task to be completed no matter what. This builds up stress in your child’s mind after having spent a substantial part of the day at school, listening to different lectures one after another. It robs them of any relaxation time, and their sleep can be disturbed if they fail to complete their homework.

2. Reduces Time for Extracurricular Activities

At times, the homework assigned for the day can be quite large, or it could be quite daunting for your kid since it is a subject he is not well-versed in. This could require spending a lot of time finishing the homework, which results in no time spent with the family or playing a few hours with friends. Gradually, this begins to affect their social skills since all they can do and focus on is completing the homework (3).

3. Promotes Surface Learning

Some students may rush through homework to complete it, focusing on rote memorisation rather than truly understanding the material, which can lead to surface learning instead of deep comprehension.

4. Encourages Academic Dishonesty

Failure to complete homework can lead to the child resorting to immoral activities just to avoid punishment. This results in cheating, where your child might copy the homework from somebody else’s notebook. Doing it once could make him realise how easy it is and resort to it more often, removing any kind of learning activity that homework is supposed to provide in the first place.

5. Creates Inequality

Not all students have access to a conducive learning environment at home, which can create disparities in their ability to complete homework effectively (1).

6. Encourages a One-Size-Fits-All Approach

Homework assignments often fail to consider individual learning styles and needs, potentially stifling creativity and limiting personalised learning opportunities.

FAQs

1. What is the primary purpose of assigning homework?

Homework reinforces classroom learning, provides additional practice, and helps students develop good study habits and time management skills.

2. How much homework is considered appropriate for different age groups?

The amount of homework typically increases with age. For younger students, about 10 minutes per grade level per night is a general guideline, while high school students might have 1-2 hours of homework per night (2).

3. Are there alternatives to traditional homework?

Yes, alternatives such as project-based learning, experiential activities, and in-class assignments can also support learning without the negative aspects of traditional homework.

The very reason for schooling is to make sure your child learns new things, gains knowledge, and develops the skills that will help him later in life. This could make you question why kids should not have homework at all. But things aren’t as black and white as they seem. Since most schools are set on assigning homework, the best thing you can do as a parent is try your best to attain a balance between school life and home life and try to ease things up for your child.

References/Resources:

1. Lathan. J; Is Homework Necessary? Education Inequity and Its Impact on Students; University of San Diego; https://onlinedegrees.sandiego.edu/education-inequity-and-homework/

2. Should Students Have Homework?; Western Governors University; https://www.wgu.edu/blog/should-students-have-homework1808.html

3. McNutt. C; this is why we should stop giving homework; Human Restoration Project; https://www.humanrestorationproject.org/writing/this-is-why-we-should-stop-giving-homework

4. Moskowitz. E; Why homework matters; The Thomas B. Fordham Institute; https://fordhaminstitute.org/national/commentary/why-homework-matters

5. Should Teachers Still Give Homework?; Point Loma Nazarene University; https://www.pointloma.edu/resources/education/should-teachers-still-give-homework

Also Read:

Essay On Homework
Effective Tips for Helping Kids in Homework
Tips to Improve Your Child’s Concentration
How to Set Up a Perfect Homework Station for Kids?
How to Help Children in Doing Holiday Homework While Enjoying Vacation?

Our Editorial Policy

Parenting is a huge responsibility, for you as a caregiver, but also for us as a parenting content platform. We understand that and take our responsibility of creating credible content seriously. FirstCry Parenting articles are written and published only after extensive research using factually sound references to deliver quality content that is accurate, validated by experts, and completely reliable. To understand how we go about creating content that is credible, read our editorial policy here.